Windrush scandal was ‘forseeable and avoidable’ – report finds

The Windrush scandal was “forseeable and avoidable” and victims were let down by the Home Office’s “systemic operational failings”, according to a report.

An independent review found the government department demonstrated “institutional ignorance and thoughtlessness” towards the issue of race and the history of the Windrush generation.

However, the report found the Home Office’s actions did not satisfy all of the features of institutional racism.

The Windrush Lessons Learned Review was commissioned after people with a right to live in the UK were wrongfully detained or deported to the Caribbean.

The report called for Home Office ministers to admit that serious harm was inflicted on people who are British and to provide an “unqualified apology” to those affected and the wider black African-Caribbean community.

Commonwealth citizens who arrived before 1973 were automatically granted indefinite leave to remain
Image: The Empire Windrush brought settlers from the Caribbean over to the UK after the Second World War

Wendy Williams, the report’s author, said: “Warning signs from both inside and outside the Home Office were apparent for a number of years, and even when stories began to emerge in 2017 in the media about high-profile injustices, I have concluded that the Home Office was still too slow to react.

“I talk about a culture of disbelief and carelessness when dealing with applications.

More from Windrush

“This was born out of a conviction that the hostile environment policy would be effective, was effective, and should be pursued at all costs.

“I have also talked about a culture of ignorance and thoughtlessness when dealing with matters of race, the Windrush generation, their history and circumstances.

“The Windrush generation were let down by systemic operational failings by the Home Office.”

Recommendations in the report include commissioning a full review and evaluation of the hostile environment policy, and that the Home Office should establish an overarching strategic race advisory board.

Ms Williams said the Windrush group had been “trapped by the hostile environment policy net”.

She added: “Those without documents were set, some would say, an impossible task.

“Others would say an unreasonably high standard of proof to prove their status.

“And when they couldn’t, they were subject to the most appalling injustice and that included the things we have heard; losing jobs, losing homes, losing access to services like healthcare, and in extreme circumstances being removed, being locked up and as we heard in one case, dying.”

The report “carefully considered” whether the concept of institutional racism outlined by Sir William Macpherson in the inquiry into the death of Stephen Lawrence was “directly relevant to describe what occurred”.

Theresa May spoke in the Commons for the first time since returning to the backbenches
Image: The hostile environment policy was in place when Theresa May was home secretary

The inquiry found that although the case for institutional racism was supported by a number of factors, the Home Office did not satisfy the definition in full.

It said: “I have not found, on the evidence that I have reviewed, that the organisational failings satisfy the Macpherson definition in full.

“Nevertheless, although the context for the Macpherson Inquiry was different to this lessons learned review, I have serious concerns that the factors I have set out in this section demonstrate an institutional ignorance and thoughtlessness towards the issue of race and the history of the Windrush generation.”

More than 8,000 people have been given “some form of documentation” and the immigration status has been confirmed for almost 2,500 since the scandal emerged in 2018, according to the most recent figures from the Home Office.

The department identified 164 people who had been deported or put in detention since 2002 amid the Windrush scandal, records said.

A compensation scheme with an estimated budget of at least £200m has been set up.

18 Windrush members wrongfully removed or detained
Image: Members of the Windrush generation were wrongfully detained

But campaigners last month hit out at the “paltry” number of people who have so far received payments and said the process was “slow and onerous”.

A total of £62,198 was paid out up until the end of last year and shared between just 36 people, despite the department receiving more than 1,000 claims so far.

Home Secretary Priti Patel has said people from the Windrush generation were subject to “insensitive treatment by the very country they called home”.

Making a statement to MPs on Thursday, she said: “As this review makes clear, some members of this generation suffered terrible injustices spurred by institutional failings spanning successive governments over several decades – including ignorance and thoughtlessness towards the race and history of the Windrush generation.”

Shadow home secretary Diane Abbott said that the opposition front bench was not given a copy of the report by the Home Secretary ahead of her statement.